Liberalism and Hierarchy: A Tension-filled Relationship as Seen from Social Anthropology
Keywords:
Ladislav Holy, liberalism, Louis Dumont, hierarchy, egalitarianism , ethnography, cultural liberalismAbstract
Ladislav Holy made the distinction between representations, ideals, and behaviour central to his theoretical and methodological reflections. That distinction underlies many of the political and ecological problems that humankind faces today, including the problems currently faced by liberalism. Using an understanding of hierarchy derived from Louis Dumont, and ethnographic case studies of attempts to impart the ideals of liberalism around the world (including in eastern Europe), I argue for a liberalism that acknowledges the embeddedness of hierarchy in many contexts and that practises the anthropological virtues of empathy, scepticism, and tolerance of alternative views.
References
Adhikari, Krishna P., and David N. Gellner. 2016. New Identity Politics and the 2012 Collapse of Nepal’s Constituent Assembly: When the Dominant becomes ‘Other’. Modern Asian Studies 50 (6): 2009–2040.
Banerjee, Mukulika. 2014. Why India Votes? London: Routledge.
Banerjee, Mukulika. 2022. Cultivating Democracy: Politics and Citizenship in Agrarian India. New York: OUP.
Burnyeat, Gwen. 2022. The Face of Peace: Government Pedagogy amid Disinformation in Colombia. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Celtel, André. 2005. Categories of the Self: Louis Dumont’s Theory of the Individual. New York and Oxford: Berghahn.
Chandra, Uday, Heierstad, Geir, and Nielsen, Kenneth Bo (eds). 2016. The Politics of Caste in West Bengal. New Delhi: Routledge India.
Dumont, Louis. 1979. The Anthropological Community and Ideology. Social Science Information 18 (6): 785–817.
Dumont, Louis. 1980a. Homo Hierarchicus: The Caste System and its Implications (complete revd English ed.). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Dumont, Louis. 1980b. On Value. Proceedings of the British Academy 66: 207–41. Republished HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 3 (1): 287–315.
Dumont, Louis. 1986. Essays on Individualism: Modern Ideology in Anthropological Perspective. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Dzenovska, D. 2018. School of Europeanness: Tolerance and Other Lessons in Political Liberalism in Latvia. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
Dzenovska, D. 2021. Liberalism in the Breach. Social Anthropology 29 (2): 490–4.
Fedirko, Taras, Samanani, Farhan, and Williamson, Hugh F. 2021. Grammars of Liberalism. Social Anthropology 29 (2): 377–88.
Ferguson, James. 2015. Give a Man a Fish: Reflections on the New Politics of Distribution. Durham: Duke University Press.
Fischer, Kathrin. 2023. Landscapes of Opportunity: Rethinking Migration Decisions in Nepal. DPhil Thesis, University of Oxford.
Galey, Jean-Claude. 1984. Différences, Valeurs, Hiérarchie: Textes Offerts à Louis Dumont. Paris: EHESS.
Geertz, Clifford. 1988. Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author. Cambridge: Polity.
Gellner, David N. 2001. The Anthropology of Buddhism and Hinduism: Weberian Themes. Delhi: OUP.
Gellner, David N. 2010. Why are the British so Peculiar? Reflections on Sport, Nationalism, and Hierarchy. JASO-online (NS) 2 (1–2): 31–43.
Gellner, David N. 2012. Uncomfortable Antinomies: Going Beyond Methodological Nationalism in Social and Cultural Anthropology. In Beyond Methodological Nationalism: Research Methodologies for Cross-Border Studies, edited by Anna Ammelina, Devrimsel D. Nergiz, Thomas Faist, and Nina Glick Schiller. New York: Routledge: 111–28. Also an Austrian Academy of Sciences Working Paper in Social Anthropology (http://epub.oeaw.ac.at/0xc1aa500d_0x002c6f4f.pdf).
Gellner, David N. 2016. The Idea of Nepal (M.C. Regmi Lecture 2016). http://soscbaha.org/mcrl-2016/.
Gellner, David N. 2020. Changing Questions? Reflections on Social Anthropology in and out of Oxford since the 1980s. In After Society: Anthropological Trajectories Out of Oxford, edited by Joao de Pina-Cabral and Glenn Bowman. Oxford: Berghahn: 105–26.
Gellner, David N. 2022. Introduction: Social Anthropology as Scepticism, Empathy, and Holism. In Re-Creating Anthropology: Sociality, Matter, and the Imagination, edited by David N. Gellner and Dolores P. Martinez. London: Routledge: 1–15.
Gellner, David N. 2023. Review of Burnyeat (2022). In JASO-online (NS) 15: 287–9.
Gellner, David N. 2024. The Persistence of Hierarchy: Paradoxes of Dominance in Nepal and Beyond. Sociological Bulletin. Online first: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/00380229241230721
Gellner, David N., and Adhikari, Krishna P. (eds). 2024. Nepal’s Dalits in Transition. Kathmandu: Vajra.
Gellner, David N., and Sondra L. Hausner. 2013. Multiple versus Unitary Belonging: How Nepalis in Britain Deal with Religion. In Social Identities between the Sacred and the Secular, edited by Abby Day, Giselle Vincett, and Christopher R. Cotter. Farnham and Burlington VT: Ashgate: 75–88.
Gellner, David N., Pfaff-Czarnecka, Joanna, and Whelpton, John (eds). 2008. Nationalism and Ethnicity in Nepal. Kathmandu: Vajra. [First ed. Harwood, 1997, as Nationalism and Ethnicity in a Hindu Kingdom.]
Graeber, David. 2018. Afterword: The Rise of Hierarchy. In Hierarchy and Value: Comparative Perspectives on Moral Order, edited by Jason Hickel and Naomi Haynes. New York and Oxford: Berghahn: 135–50.
Hachhethu, Krishna. 2002. Party Building in Nepal, Organization, Leadership and People: A Comparative Study of the Nepali Congress and the Communist Party of Nepal (Unified Marxist-Leninist). Kathmandu: Mandala Book Point.
Hann, Chris. 2019. Repatriating Polanyi: Market Society in the Visegrad States. Budapest: CEU Press.
Hausner, Sondra L., and Gellner, David N. 2012. Category and Practice as Two Aspects of Religion: The Case of Nepalis in Britain. Journal of the American Academy of Religion 80 (4): 971–97.
Haynes, Naomi and Hickel, Jason. 2018. Introduction: Hierarchy, Value, and the Value of Hierarchy. In Hierarchy and Value: Comparative Perspectives on Moral Order, edited by Jason Hickel and Naomi Haynes. New York and Oxford: Berghahn: 1–21.
Hirsch, Eric and Gellner, David N. 2003. Introduction: Ethnography of Organizations and Organizations of Ethnography. Inside Organizations: Anthropologists at Work, edited by David N. Gellner and Eric Hirsch. Oxford: Berg: 1–15.
Holy, Ladislav. 1996. The Little Czech and the Great Czech Nation: National Identity and the Post-Communist Transformation of Society. Cambridge: University Press.
Holy, Ladislav and Stuchlik, Milan. 1983. Actions, Norms and Representations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Itéanu, André, and Moya, Ismaël. 2015. Mister D.: Radical Comparison, Values, and Ethnographic Theory. HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 5 (1): 113–36.
Jodhka, Surinder S., and Manor, James. 2018. Introduction. In Contested Hierarchies, Persisting Influence: Caste and Power in Twenty-First Century India, edited by Surinder S. Jodhka and James Manor. Hyderabad: Orient Blackswan: 1–36.
Kapferer, Bruce. 1988. Legends of People, Myths of State: Violence, Intolerance, and Political Culture in Sri Lanka and Australia. Washington DC: Smithsonian. (2nd revd ed. 2011, Berghahn.)
Kapferer, Bruce. 2010. Louis Dumont and a Holist Anthropology. In Experiments in Holism: Theory and Practice in Contemporary Anthropology, edited by Ton Otto and Nils Bubandt. Oxford: Blackwell: 213–38.
Kapferer, Bruce. 2013. How Anthropologists Think: Configurations of the Exotic. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute (N.S.) 19: 813–36.
Kesavan, Mukul 2008. Against South Asia. Himal Southasian (August). www.himalmag.com/against-southasia/
Koch, Insa. 2017. What’s in a Vote? Brexit Beyond Culture Wars. American Ethnologist 44 (2): 225–30.
Koch, Insa. 2018. Personalizing the State: An Anthropology of Law, Politics, and Welfare in Austerity Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kothari, Rajni. 1970. Politics in India. Delhi: Orient Longman.
Laidlaw, James. 2014. The Subject of Virtue: An Anthropology of Ethics and Freedom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Malinowski, Bronislaw. 1922. Argonauts of the Western Pacific: An Account of Native Enterprise and Adventure in the Archipelagos of Melanesian New Guinea. London: George Routledge & Sons.
Malinowski, Bronislaw. 1944. Freedom and Civilization. New York: Roy Publishers.
Mamdani, Mahmood. 2022. Neither Settler nor Native: The Making and Unmaking of Permanent Minorities. Cambridge MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
McConnell, Fiona. 2016. Rehearsing the State: The Political Practices of the Tibetan Government-in-Exile. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
Menon, Dilip. 2020. Is Hierarchy the Same as Inequality? In Inequality Studies from the Global South, edited by David Francis, Imraan Valodia, and Edward Webster. London: Routledge: 22–32.
Michelutti, Lucia. 2008. The Vernacularisation of Democracy: Politics, Caste, and Religion. New Delhi: Routledge.
Michelutti, Lucia, Hoque, Ashraf, Martin, Nicolas, Picherit, David, Rollier, Paul, Ruud, Arild E., and Still, Clarinda. 2018. Mafia Raj: The Rule of Bosses in South Asia. Redwood City: Stanford University Press.
Mill, John Stuart. 2010 (1861). Considerations on Representative Government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mosko, Mark S. 1994. Transformations of Dumont: The Hierarchical, the Sacred, and the Profane in India and Ancient Hawaii. History and Anthropology 7 (1–4): 19–86.
Parkin, Robert. 2003. Louis Dumont and Hierarchical Opposition. New York and Oxford: Berghahn.
Pfaff-Czarnecka, Joanna. 2022. Belonging in Motion: Contested Social Boundaries in South Asia. Kathmandu: Social Science Baha.
Piliavsky, Anastasia. 2021. Nobody’s People: Hierarchy as Hope in a Society of Thieves. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Rio, Knut M., and Smedal, Olaf H. (eds). 2009. Hierarchy: Persistence and Transformation in Social Formations. New York and Oxford: Berghahn.
Robbins, Joel. 2007. Continuity Thinking and the Problem of Christian Culture: Belief, Time, and the Anthropology of Christianity. Current Anthropology 48 (1): 5–38.
Robbins, Joel. 2009. Conversion, Hierarchy, and Cultural Change: Value and Syncretism in the Globalization of Pentecostal and Charismatic Christianity. In Persistence and Transformation in Social Forms, edited by Knut Rio and Olaf H. Smedal. New York: Berghahn: 65–88.
Robbins, Joel. 2013. Monism, Pluralism, and the Structure of Value Relations: A Dumontian Contribution to the Contemporary Study of Value. Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 3 (1): 99–115.
Robbins, Joel. 2015. Dumont’s Hierarchical Dynamism: Christianity and Individualism Revisited. Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 5 (1): 173–95.
Sarró, Ramon. 2022. Crisis, Prophecy, and Ethnography: Living in a Waste Land Then and Now. In Re-Creating Anthropology: Sociality, Matter, and the Imagination, edited by David N. Gellner and Dolores P. Martinez. London and New York: Routledge: 57–68.
Shah, Alpa. 2024. The Incarcerations: BK-16 and the Search for Democracy in India. Glasgow: HarperCollins Publishers.
Snellinger, Amanda. 2018. Making New Nepal: From Student Activism to Mainstream Politics. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Spencer, Jonathan. 1990a. Collective Violence and Everyday Practice in Sri Lanka. Modern Asian Studies 24 (3): 603–23.
Spencer, Jonathan. 1990b. Writing Within: Anthropology, Nationalism, and Culture in Sri Lanka [and Comments and Reply]. Current Anthropology 31 (3): 283–300.
Tanabe, Akio. 2007. Toward Vernacular Democracy: Moral Society and Post-postcolonial Transformation in Rural Orissa, India. American Ethnologist 34 (3): 558–74.
Wilkerson, Isabel. 2020. Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents. New York: Random House.
